MagSubscribe

Business

INT. AGENCY - LUNCH

Who gets the ten percent?

Managers, agents and lawyers: what they're good for, what they cost, where things blow up, the big names, and how a writer with no representation gets through the door. A view from the American and British markets.

By the Scriptopus Mag desk · Edited by Ali25 Oct 202615 min read

The Creative Artists Agency headquarters building in Century City, Los Angeles.
The Creative Artists Agency building at 2000 Avenue of the Stars, Century City. Photo: Minnaert, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and shown in greyscale. Source
Agent ~10%
What they do
Find work, negotiate, close the deal.
Who regulates them
Licensed in California, and signed with the Writers Guild.
Weak spot
Too many clients, too little time. Small clients wait their turn.
Manager ~10–15%
What they do
Plan the career, read the drafts, open doors.
Who regulates them
Hardly anyone. Managers aren't licensed the way agents are.
Weak spot
They can also attach themselves to your project as a producer.
Lawyer ~5%
What they do
Read the contract, negotiate the terms.
Who regulates them
The bar and its rules of professional conduct.
Weak spot
Finding you work isn't really their job.
The representation catch-22
CreditRep

You need a credit to get a representative, and you need a representative to get a credit. The second half of this piece is about how to break that loop.

A screenwriter's career has two big moments. The first is finishing that first script. The second is the day someone calls and says, “We'd like to represent you.” Plenty of young writers dream about the second moment more than the first, because they believe that call will open every door.

This piece is about that call, minus the romance. What working with a manager or an agent actually gets you, what it costs, where the relationship gets strained, and how a writer with no representation at all can still have a career. Our examples come mostly from the American and British markets, because that's where the system of representation is most developed and most fought over.

OneAgent, manager, lawyer: who's who?

In the American system, a screenwriter usually has three different people in their corner, and each one does a different job.

The agent finds the work and makes the deal. In California, agents have to be licensed by law, and agents who have signed with the Writers Guild are generally capped at a ten percent commission. In the eyes of the law, finding a writer a job is the agent's business.

The manager runs the career. A manager reads your drafts, gives notes, talks through which projects to chase and which to steer clear of, and introduces you to the right people. Managers aren't licensed the way agents are, and they usually take between ten and fifteen percent. There's one more difference: managers can also come on board as producers on their own clients' projects.

The lawyer reads the contract and negotiates the terms. In the US, many entertainment lawyers take about five percent of the deal instead of billing by the hour.

In Britain the setup is simpler. Managers are less common, and a single agent usually handles both the career and the deals. In many European countries, a large share of screenwriters work with no representative at all.

TwoWhat does a representative get you?

The door

Most big production companies and studios won't accept a script from someone without representation. That isn't snobbery. It's the idea-theft lawsuits we covered in our piece on stolen ideas. Companies are afraid of being sued if they develop a project that looks like a script someone sent them unsolicited. A representative is the key that gets you through that door.

The haggling

Talking money with a producer is hard, especially when you'll be sitting across from that same producer in a creative meeting next week. Your representative has that conversation for you. When they have to, they play bad cop, and your creative relationship stays intact.

The grapevine

Which studio is looking for a writer for which project, what a particular producer is into, which platform isn't buying which genre. This kind of thing rarely gets published anywhere. It travels by phone and over lunch. A good representative is plugged into it.

Strategy

A good manager will also tell you which jobs to turn down. Write two projects in the wrong genre early on, and you can spend years as that genre's writer. On calls like these, the manager is the pair of eyes looking in from outside.

ThreeWhat does a representative cost?

The commissions add up

A writer with an agent, a manager and a lawyer can end up handing about a quarter of their pre-tax earnings to their representatives. Early in a career, that hurts. That's why many writers start out with just a manager, or just a lawyer.

When your manager is also a producer

The fact that managers can attach themselves to projects as producers is one of the most disputed parts of the relationship. On the one hand, it gives the manager a stake in the project and makes them more invested in it. Mason Novick serving as both Diablo Cody's manager and a producer of Juno is an example of it working well. On the other hand, adding another producer's fee and credit can make a project harder to sell. How will your manager balance your interests against their own as a producer? Ask that question out loud, right at the start.

Agency packaging fees and the 2019 crisis

The biggest example of a representative's interests splitting from the client's was the 2019 fight between the Writers Guild of America and the big agencies. For years, when the big agencies sold a series to a studio as a “package,” bundled with its writer, director and cast, they collected a fee directly from the studio. As the guild saw it, that left the agency looking after the studio's interests instead of the client's. The agencies had also started launching their own production companies, which meant they sometimes ended up on the other side of the table from their own clients, as the employer.

In April 2019 the guild put a new code of conduct into effect, and when the big agencies refused to sign it, over seven thousand writers sent their agencies termination letters on the same day. The fight dragged on for about two years. Through 2020 and 2021 the agencies made their peace with the guild one by one, and packaging fees ended entirely in 2022. The crisis reminded writers of something important: your representative speaks for you, but isn't always speaking for your wallet.

Your representative should be your voice. To know whose voice they really are, start by finding out who pays them.

FourWhat everyone assumes, and what's true

“A manager finds you work.”

Partly. A manager opens doors, but it's your script that has to walk through them. Even the best manager can't do much for a writer who doesn't have a good script. Our rule of thumb at the desk: a representative doesn't find the work. They make it bigger.

“The biggest agency is the best.”

Not always. Big agencies have clout, but their client lists are very long. A writer early in their career can end up at the bottom of the list at a big agency. At a smaller agency or a boutique management company, the same writer could be a priority.

“You can't get into this business without a representative.”

To break into the American studio system, a representative matters a great deal in practice. But as we'll see below, plenty of writers started out without one and found representation later.

FiveThe big names

This isn't a ranking. It's a selection of the names you'll hear most often in the industry. Any of them may merge, change hands or be renamed over the years.

The big names
US: agencies
CAA, WME, UTA, Gersh
US: management
Anonymous Content, Circle of Confusion, Madhouse Entertainment, Grandview, Management 360, Kaplan/Perrone
UK: agencies
Curtis Brown, United Agents, Casarotto Ramsay & Associates, Independent Talent

Several of the big agencies have merged in recent years. ICM, for example, became part of CAA in 2022. So always check a current list to see who represents whom.

SixGetting in without a representative

There are a few proven ways to beat the catch-22. None of them is guaranteed, but every one has launched real careers.

A voice people notice

We told Diablo Cody's story in our piece on writers and producers. The posts she wrote on her own blog caught a manager's eye. The manager suggested she try writing a screenplay, and the result was Juno. Cody did need a representative, but it was the representative who found her. What made that happen was a voice that was out in public and sounded like nobody else.

Competitions and fellowships

The Nicholl Fellowships, awarded since 1986 by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the organization behind the Oscars, are one of the most prestigious doors open to unrepresented writers. The Austin Film Festival's screenplay competition is another one the industry follows closely. Writing programs at the big studios and networks, the Sundance screenwriting labs and, in Britain, the BBC's open calls do the same job. Lists like the Scriptopus events guide make it easier to keep track of their deadlines.

The Black List

In 2005 Franklin Leonard started a survey that asked studio executives for their favorite scripts of the year that hadn't been made yet. The list quickly became one of the most talked-about in the business, and some of the scripts on it went on to become films that won the Oscar for Best Picture. Since 2012 the Black List has also run a platform where writers can upload their scripts and have professional readers rate them. Scripts that score well can end up on the radar of representatives and producers.

Starting on the inside

Many television writers got their start as assistants in a writers' room: taking notes, cleaning up drafts, watching how the room works. It's a slow road, but one of the most natural ways to build relationships inside the industry.

Short films and other media

A short film that actually got made gets noticed faster than a script nobody has read. A play, a novel or a podcast can put a writer's voice out there the same way. Representatives keep an eye on those places too.

SevenTips for working with a representative

  1. Advice

    Ask questions at the first meeting.

    Who do they represent? What's their plan for your first year? How often will you talk? What do they expect from you?

  2. Advice

    Get the producing question in writing.

    From the very start, talk about whether your manager will attach themselves to your projects as a producer and, if so, on what terms.

  3. Advice

    Know how long the contract runs and how to get out.

    Find out how you'd part ways if things don't work out, and which jobs they'd still take a commission on afterward.

  4. Advice

    Don't leave everything to your representative.

    Keep building your own relationships and chasing your own leads. The best representatives like working with a writer who is also finding their own way in.

  5. Advice

    Finish the script before you go looking for a representative.

    Show up with a script that's ready to be read, not a half-baked idea. You only get one first impression.

  6. Advice

    Changing representatives is normal.

    You may need different representatives at different stages of your career. When you leave, be kind and be clear. It's a small industry.

LastDo you need one?

In the American studio system, especially on big projects, a representative is all but essential in practice. In independent film, international co-productions and the world of competitions and funding, going it alone is possible, and even common.

But one rule holds in both worlds: a representative finds you once a good script has made you visible. The best thing you can do while you wait for that call is write the script that makes the phone ring.

FADE OUT.Scriptopus Mag

Share this piece

Pass it to a writer who would like it.

XLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Keep reading

Scriptopus Mag · Published by Scriptopus. Every piece is free to read.How Scriptopus Mag is made · Pictures via Wikimedia Commons, credited under each one · @scriptopusapp