MagSubscribe

Business

INT. PRODUCTION OFFICE - DAY

Same boat, different ports

Writer and producer want the same film, but for different reasons. Where their interests line up and where they split, and how a writer selling a first script and one breaking sales records turn into two very different people at the same table.

By the Scriptopus Mag desk · Edited by Ali and Umut23 Oct 202615 min read

The novelist Winston Groom speaking at an event in 2014.
Winston Groom, author of Forrest Gump, speaking in 2014. Photo: Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and shown in greyscale. Source
Who wants what? A generalization, but a familiar one
IssueProducerScreenwriterWhere they meet
The scriptA package that sellsThe right storyA good film that can actually be shot
TimeA fast draftThe right draftA delivery schedule in writing
MoneyA low fee up front, a share laterA high fee up frontThe film actually getting made
RightsAll rights, foreverA share in sequels and adaptations, a reversion clauseA clearly written contract
NotesWhat the star and the financier wantThe integrity of the storyA character the audience will care about
CreditA producer credit, the Best Picture awardThe screenplay creditThe next job, for both of them
The first script The producer sizes you up
Your hand
The script, and nothing else
Pay
Close to the minimum, often with an option
Risk
Unpaid work that arrives as “just one more draft”
Rights
Often signed away entirely
The established writer You size up the producer
Your hand
A name, past hits, competing offers
Pay
A high fee up front, sometimes a share of the box office
Risk
A high price brings high expectations
Rights
Directing, producing and approval rights

A producer and a screenwriter are a little like a ship's captain and its navigator. They're on the same ship, and they both want to get somewhere. The navigator is looking for the right port. The captain wants to get the ship into a port, on time and without sinking. Most days those two goals point the same way. Some days they don't.

This piece is about those days. Where producer and writer want different things, how the relationship changes as a career moves along, and real cases from film history, some that ended well and some that didn't.

OneA screenplay is a story, and also a piece of property

To the writer, a screenplay is a story. To the producer it's also property. It gets bought, sold and optioned, handed to another writer for a rewrite, left on a shelf for years. Most of the tension between the two comes from that double nature.

The producer's job is to turn the script into a package: a director, a star or two, a financier, a distributor. The script sits at the center of that package, but it isn't the package. So the producer keeps trying to make the script fit the other pieces. The star wants more to do in the second act. The financier wants a more hopeful ending. The streamer insists on a set running time. The writer reads every one of those requests and asks whether the story still holds together.

None of this comes from bad faith. It comes from different jobs. The writer answers for the story. The producer answers for that story existing at all. Both are right, and the relationship breaks down the moment either one won't accept that the other is right too.

TwoProfit on paper, profit in your pocket

Writer and producer split hardest where the money gets divided, and the most instructive cases in film history tend to come after big hits.

Winston Groom sold the film rights to his novel Forrest Gump for $350,000 and three percent of the film's net profits. The film came out in 1994 and took about $678 million worldwide. Groom was then told that, by the studio's books, it had lost over $60 million. His three percent was worth nothing. Groom threatened to sue, and the lawyer he hired was the same one who had represented Art Buchwald in the Coming to America case we covered in our piece on idea lawsuits. In the end the two sides settled. Around the same time, the studio paid a high price for the rights to Groom's sequel novel.

The industry has a name for this: “Hollywood accounting.” Net profit is whatever is left once the studio has taken off expenses, interest and distribution fees, all of them figures the studio sets itself. Even on very successful films, that number often lands somewhere near zero. The lesson is simple. A share of the net is a promise. Money up front and a share of the gross are money.

ThreeNegotiating a first script: Rocky

Early in a career, a writer has exactly one card to play: the script. Sylvester Stallone played his in one of the most famous negotiations in film history.

In the mid-1970s Stallone was a broke actor. When he wrote Rocky, the studios were interested, but they wanted a star like Burt Reynolds or Ryan O'Neal in the lead. The offers went as high as $360,000. Stallone wouldn't sell unless he played the lead himself. Part of the reason was that he had once let another script of his go for very little, and he didn't want to make the same mistake twice.

The producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff said yes, on a much smaller budget. By some accounts they even put their own houses on the line to guarantee it. Stallone got about $35,000 for the script and the role, plus a share of the net profits. The film became a legend and launched his career.

There's another side to the story, though. Stallone says openly now that he owns no part of the Rocky franchise. The rights stayed with the producers and the studio. The deal got him a career, but not a property. When you sell a first script you usually get to pick money, control or ownership. You rarely get all three.

Early on, the script is the only card you hold. Before you put it on the table, know what you're playing for. Money? The role? Ownership?

FourWhen power changes hands: the spec boom

The late 1980s and the 1990s were the golden age of the “spec” script in American film: a script nobody ordered, written on the writer's own initiative and then put up for sale. For a while, the balance of power between writer and producer flipped.

Shane Black's career shows it best. His script for Lethal Weapon (1987) sold for about $250,000. A few years later The Last Boy Scout went for $1.75 million, and in 1994 The Long Kiss Goodnight sold for $4 million, at the time the highest price ever paid for a screenplay. Joe Eszterhas's Basic Instinct had already gone at auction in 1990 for about $3 million. M. Night Shyamalan sold The Sixth Sense for a big fee and on one condition: he would direct it himself.

In deals like these, the producer was no longer the one who found the script. The producer was the one racing to land it. A high price came at a cost, though. Every record-breaking script arrived with huge expectations attached. The Long Kiss Goodnight fell short of them at the box office, and its record price hung over almost everything written about the film. When power passes to the writer, so does the responsibility.

FiveThe good producer: the writer's first reader and last defender

We don't want this piece to paint producers as people who only look after their own interests. Film history is full of producers who launched writers' careers, protected them and took risks on their stories.

Diablo Cody was living in Minneapolis and writing her own blog when Mason Novick started reading it. He found her voice so fresh that he called her and asked whether she had ever thought about writing a screenplay. The one she went on to write was Juno. In 2008 it won her the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay, and Novick, as one of the film's producers, got a Best Picture nomination. Here the producer found the writer before she was a writer at all.

Michael and Julia Phillips backed Paul Schrader's Taxi Driver when nobody wanted it, and put it in the hands of the right director. Winkler and Chartoff risked their houses on Rocky. These producers didn't always want what the writer wanted. But they put something of their own on the line so the story could exist.

Here's one way to spot a good producer. When they talk about your script, are they talking about the story or the package? They have to talk about both. But if the first thing out of their mouth is about the story, you've probably found a good partner.

SixWhere the fights usually start

The free draft

Early in a career, this is the fight writers hit most often: a new draft, requested as “a small revision,” that really means starting over from page one. The Writers Guild of America has campaigned against this kind of unpaid work for years. The simplest way out of the trap is a contract that spells out how many drafts and how many revisions you'll write.

Another writer

Producers bring in another writer for a rewrite all the time, and for the first writer it usually hurts. In the US, the guild decides who gets credit, and its rules lean toward protecting the first writer. On an original screenplay, for example, a writer who comes in later has to have contributed over half of the script to be credited.

The script on the shelf

When a script sells and then sits unmade for years, the industry calls it “development hell.” The script isn't yours anymore, but nobody else is making it either. That's what a reversion clause is for: if the film isn't made within a set time, the rights go back to the writer, or the writer can buy them back.

SevenWays to keep the relationship working

Enough observation. Here are a few practical tips, all of them tested at the table.

  1. Advice

    Have a lawyer read the contract.

    Especially the first one. A contract you sign in a rush of excitement can follow you for years.

  2. Advice

    Don't count on a share of the net.

    What matters is the money up front and, if you can get it, a share of the gross. Think of a net share as a gift: nice if it ever shows up.

  3. Advice

    Put the number of drafts in writing.

    How many drafts, how many revisions, on what schedule. Anything past that gets paid separately.

  4. Advice

    Find out early what the producer is aiming for.

    Which streamer, what budget, which actor? Most of the notes you get will grow out of those answers.

  5. Advice

    Ask for a reversion clause.

    Don't let your script rot on a shelf. After a set time, the rights should come back to you.

  6. Advice

    Know what you want.

    Money, control, ownership. Stallone picked control and got a career out of it, but he gave up ownership. Choose with your eyes open.

  7. Advice

    Think in careers, not projects.

    The producer you work with today could open the door to another project tomorrow. Or shut it.

LastThe same boat

Writer and producer are two passengers headed for the same port for different reasons. Pretending otherwise won't save the relationship. Talking about it openly will. Ask “What do you want from this film, and what do I want?” at the first meeting, and you'll head off most of the fights at the last one.

And remember: the best producers know a script is property, but they don't read it like property. The best writers know a script is a story, but they never forget that it's property too.

FADE OUT.Scriptopus Mag

Share this piece

Pass it to a writer who would like it.

XLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Keep reading

Scriptopus Mag · Published by Scriptopus. Every piece is free to read.How Scriptopus Mag is made · Pictures via Wikimedia Commons, credited under each one · @scriptopusapp