MagSubscribe

Working together

INT. FILM SET - NIGHT

One child, two parents

The writer gives birth to the story. The director raises it. Both are sure the child takes after them. The most famous writer and director partnerships in film, their fights and the times they made up.

By the Scriptopus Mag desk · Edited by Umut20 Oct 202615 min read

The writer Aaron Sorkin and the director David Fincher with three of their actors at the 2010 New York Film Festival.
Aaron Sorkin, Jesse Eisenberg, Andrew Garfield, Justin Timberlake and David Fincher at the New York Film Festival premiere of The Social Network, 2010. Photo: Raffi Asdourian, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and shown in greyscale. Source
The poster billing

A DIRECTOR film

The Child's Name

Producer · Cast · Cinematography · Editing · Music
Screenplay by THE SCREENWRITER

Who gets the spotlight, and when? An observation, not a rule
SituationDirectorScreenwriter
FestivalOnstage, at the micIn the audience, third row
Reviews“X's new film”One sentence, in one paragraph
AwardsIts own categoryIts own category
Failure“The script was weak”“That's not what I wrote”
On a TV seriesA guestThe host

Success has many fathers. Failure is an orphan.

Between the day a screenplay is born and the day the film opens, two people usually go through a long and complicated relationship. It's a lot like parenthood. One of them dreamed the child up and delivered it page by page. The other will raise it, dress it and send it out into the world. Both love it. Both think it takes after them. And sooner or later, they fight about how it should be brought up.

This piece won't tell you how to manage that relationship. Instead it looks at the most famous writer and director pairs in film history: the hits, the fights, the breakups, and the reconciliations that sometimes came years later. You may recognize a bit of your own partnership in them.

OneThe inequality on the poster

Look at the billing above. The director's name is bigger than the film's title. The writer's name sits somewhere down among the cinematographer and the editor. That imbalance has a history, and the history, ironically, starts with an article written against screenwriters.

In 1954 a young critic named François Truffaut took a harsh swipe at the French cinema of the day in Cahiers du Cinéma. His targets were the screenwriters famous for their literary adaptations. As Truffaut saw it, the real author of a film was the person behind the camera: the director. The idea came to be known as auteur theory, and the American critic Andrew Sarris carried it to Hollywood in his writing. The “A film by X” on today's posters is, in large part, its legacy.

Screenwriters have objected to that line for years. The Writers Guild and the Directors Guild have been arguing over this “possessory” credit for decades. In his 1983 book Adventures in the Screen Trade, William Goldman argued that the auteur idea ignored how collaborative filmmaking is. In his view, a film's skeleton was built in the script long before any director showed up.

Auteur theory, ironically, was born as an attack on screenwriters. They have been answering it ever since.

TwoA partnership born of rivalry: Schrader and Scorsese

Paul Schrader wrote Taxi Driver on spec, during a dark stretch of his life. With backing from the producers Michael and Julia Phillips, the script found its way to Martin Scorsese. The film came out in 1976, and today it's remembered as “a Scorsese film.” Schrader spent years reminding interviewers that the character came out of his own loneliness.

The surprise is that the tension didn't end things. The two went on to make Raging Bull (1980), The Last Temptation of Christ (1988) and Bringing Out the Dead (1999) together. Schrader's obsession with guilt, atonement and the lonely man overlapped deeply with Scorsese's world. The rivalry never went away. A shared obsession kept feeding it.

What this partnership teaches: long partnerships tend to grow out of a shared obsession, not a shared taste. When two people look at the same wound from different sides, even their fights can get work done.

ThreeWhen the director gives the writer the spotlight

Not every partnership repeats the pecking order on the poster. Some directors go out of their way to put their writers in the light.

When Parasite won Best Original Screenplay at the 2020 Oscars, Bong Joon-ho went up on stage with his co-writer, Han Jin-won. One of the most talked-about directors in the world chose to share the award with the friend he wrote it with, and to make sure people saw him.

David Fincher's work with Aaron Sorkin on The Social Network stands out for the same reason. As we described in an earlier piece, Fincher left Sorkin's words alone and thought about how to make them go faster. He tried to understand the script before he changed it. Sorkin won an Oscar for that screenplay.

Then there's the family business. Christopher Nolan's Memento (2000) grew out of a story by his brother, Jonathan Nolan. The brothers went on to write films such as The Dark Knight and Interstellar together. Being brothers seems to have solved the trust problem between writer and director before it could start. Or at least it keeps the fights in the family.

And a rare case: films where the writer is the brand. Spike Jonze directed Being John Malkovich (1999) and Adaptation (2002), yet most film fans today call them “Charlie Kaufman films.” Kaufman's voice was so distinctive that audiences flipped the poster's hierarchy in their heads. Eventually Kaufman started directing his own scripts.

FourFights, breakups and making up

Basic Instinct and Showgirls: peace for the hit, a stage for the flop

Joe Eszterhas sold his Basic Instinct script in 1990 for about three million dollars, one of the highest prices ever paid for a screenplay up to then. Before long he and the director, Paul Verhoeven, ran into creative differences. Eszterhas saw some of the scenes Verhoeven wanted to add as exploitative, and he walked off the project along with the producer Irwin Winkler. Verhoeven went through four drafts with another writer, decided he didn't like them, and went back to a version very close to Eszterhas's original. The two made up face to face, and the film was a huge hit.

That hit brought them together once more, for Showgirls (1995), which became one of the most savaged films of its day. The interesting part came afterward. Verhoeven became the first director to show up in person at the Razzies, the awards for the year's worst films, and collect his prizes. He went up on stage and said it was more fun than reading the reviews. In a business where failure is usually an orphan, the director walked onstage and claimed the orphan as his own.

Jaws: the second writer on set

Jaws (1975) started out as drafts Peter Benchley wrote from his own novel. During the shoot, Steven Spielberg brought the writer and actor Carl Gottlieb onto the set, where Gottlieb often rewrote the next day's scenes with the actors. In the end both men shared the screenplay credit. It's one of those cases that remind us a screenplay is often the product of a process, not of one person.

Blade Runner: the thirty-five-year homecoming

Hampton Fancher wrote the first script for Blade Runner (1982). During development, Ridley Scott brought in David Peoples to rewrite it. Fancher felt shut out and drifted away from the project. Both names ended up in the credits. The sweet part came years later, when Fancher co-wrote Blade Runner 2049 (2017) with Michael Green. Thirty-five years on, he came back to his own child.

Chinatown: the fight the writer lost

The fight between Robert Towne and Roman Polanski, which we told in our previous piece, belongs on this list too. Towne lost the ending, but he won an Oscar for the script. And the dark ending the director forced on it is the one that made the film a classic.

When it's a hit, everyone says the child takes after them. When it flops, it turns out the child took after the other parent all along.

FiveA guest in film, the host in television

The balance of power between writer and director flips with the medium. In film, the director usually has the final say. The writer often isn't even invited to the set. Some directors prefer it that way: when they want to change a scene, they'd rather not see the look on the writer's face.

Television turns it around. The head writer, the showrunner we described in our piece on the writers' room, owns the show. Directors come and go episode by episode, and the writers' room guards the show's voice. The same writer who is a guest in film is the host in television. That's why so many strong screenwriters have moved to TV in recent years. There, the story belongs to the writer.

The split shapes the relationship, too. In film, a writer's power depends on how good their relationship with the director is. In television, a director's power depends on how good their relationship with the writer is.

SixThe producer's job: finding the right parents

There's an invisible third party in all this: the producer. More often than not, the producer is the one who puts writer and director together. And sometimes the producer should be the first to see that it isn't going to work.

The warning signs of a bad match usually show up in the first few meetings. The director doesn't quote a single line from the script. Or announces in the very first meeting that the ending has to change. Or the two of them, talking about the tone of the story, name completely different films. These signs don't always mean disaster. Polanski's push to change the ending of Chinatown turned out to be the best decision the film made. But the producer has to know the tension is there, make room for it, and, if it comes to that, have the nerve to change the match.

Wes Anderson's career shows how the match can change over time. Anderson wrote his first films with his college friend Owen Wilson: Bottle Rocket, Rushmore, The Royal Tenenbaums. Then Wilson turned to acting, and for his next stretch Anderson worked with Noah Baumbach. The right parent isn't necessarily the same person for every child.

SevenObservations from the desk

Not advice. Just patterns that kept turning up in these stories.

  1. Observation

    Long partnerships grow out of a shared obsession.

    Schrader and Scorsese didn't share a taste. They shared a wound.

  2. Observation

    A good director understands before changing anything.

    Fincher didn't change Sorkin's words. He figured out how to make them work.

  3. Observation

    Credit fights usually start after a hit.

    Nobody argues over the credits on a flop.

  4. Observation

    Whoever takes the blame saves the relationship.

    Verhoeven's night at the Razzies showed that even a flop can be worn with grace.

  5. Observation

    A screenplay is often a process, not a person.

    Jaws, Blade Runner, Basic Instinct: none of those scripts came from just one pair of hands.

  6. Observation

    A bad match is the producer's problem first.

    The producer is the one best placed to see early that writer and director won't get along.

  7. Observation

    People do make up.

    Fancher wrote the sequel to his own story thirty-five years later.

LastWhose child is it?

There's no single answer. Maybe the right question is a different one: did the child turn out well? A film that turned out well carries traces of both parents, whoever's name is bigger on the poster. The writer's wounds, and the director's eye.

Keep that in mind the next time you walk into a meeting. The person across the table isn't there to take your child away. They're there to raise it. You'll fight about how. There's no avoiding that. But if you both want the best for the same child, those fights can sometimes bring out the best in it.

FADE OUT.Scriptopus Mag

Share this piece

Pass it to a writer who would like it.

XLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Keep reading

Scriptopus Mag · Published by Scriptopus. Every piece is free to read.How Scriptopus Mag is made · Pictures via Wikimedia Commons, credited under each one · @scriptopusapp