MagSubscribe

Business

INT. THE SCREENWRITER'S DESK - NIGHT

The rent script and the heart script

On being caught between the script a producer has ordered and the story of your own that nobody wants. Can you do both well? Yes. Just not the way you've been told.

By the Scriptopus Mag desk · Edited by Ali1 Oct 202611 min read

Francis Ford Coppola photographed in 2011.
Francis Ford Coppola, 2011. Photo: Gerald Geronimo, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and shown in greyscale. Source
File A Commission
Subject
A woman's story, set on the Aegean
Format
8 episodes, streaming
Delivery
First two episodes, end of March
Advance
On signing
Feeling
(expected from you)

Settled over the phone. Everyone's excited. Everyone but you, so far.

File B The drawer
Subject
My father. Or that town.
Format
(undecided)
Delivery
(none)
Advance
(none)
Feeling
Hasn't let you be for three years

Taken out every summer. Put back every September.

The phone rings. The producer is polite but in a hurry. A subject, a date, a number. When you hang up you're holding three things, and the fourth is missing: why you should be the one to tell this story. You're expected to find that yourself. By the end of March, no less.

In the drawer of the same desk sits another file. The story nobody wants, nobody pays for, nobody asks about. It has no deadline. All it has is a scene that wakes you at three in the morning.

Most working screenwriters live between these two files. This piece talks about life in between without dressing it up, because most of what gets said on the subject is either a romantic lie or something we tell ourselves to feel better.

OneFirst, let's bury the romance

The common myth goes like this. Your own story is pure, and a commission is your soul for rent. Real screenwriters write what's in the drawer, and everyone else does “commercial work.”

Film history doesn't back the myth up. Francis Ford Coppola didn't want The Godfather. He found the novel cheap, and he took the job largely for the money: American Zoetrope, the company he had founded, owed Warner money. Then, inside the commission, he found his own subject. An Italian-American family, fathers and sons, the tug-of-war between loyalty to the family and being yourself. The film that came out of it is counted among his most personal work.

The reverse is true too, and it gets talked about less. Some of the files in the drawer are there because they aren't any good. “Nobody wanted it” sometimes says something about the industry's blindness. Sometimes it says the story only matters to the person who wrote it. Admitting that is much harder than taking a commission.

There's no world where the commission is dirty and your own story is clean. There are only pages that are well written and pages that aren't.

TwoAn outside subject, an inside anger

Here's the real paradox. In your own story the feeling comes first and the story second. In a commission the order flips: the subject comes first, and the feeling is yours to supply. But manufactured feeling shows on the page. A reader smells it in the first ten pages, and nobody has a better nose for it than a streaming executive.

That's why the real craft of commissioned work happens before the writing. Inside someone else's subject, you look for the door into your own wound. The woman on the Aegean may mean nothing to you. But her fight with her mother, her debt, her shame, her urge to run? One of those is yours, guaranteed. You research until you find it. Once you do, the subject is yours, and the commission is a commission only on paper.

Charlie Kaufman took this as far as it goes. He was hired to adapt Susan Orlean's book about orchids, and he couldn't. He found nothing in it that gave him a dramatic spine. In the end he made his own block the subject of the script, and Adaptation became a film about a screenwriter who can't deliver on a commission. It's not a trick everyone can repeat. But it lays the mechanism bare: if you can't find your feeling in a commission, not finding it is a feeling too, and you can use it.

Here are the practical questions we ask. What in this story makes me angry? Which character do I think understands this subject less than I do? Which scene am I afraid to write? The answer to the third is usually the heart of the script.

ThreeTurning down money is not a virtue

The high-minded advice at this point is “Don't sell your soul.” It sounds like someone who has never paid rent. Turning down a commission is usually a matter of means, not nobility. If you have a home, a kid, a debt, a commission is close to the only way to buy the time to write the story in the drawer.

But every yes is a no to something else. Ben Hecht was one of the best-paid screenwriters in Hollywood. He was fast, he knew his trade, and he didn't much like the business. People still tell the story of how he reworked the script of Gone with the Wind in about a week. Nobody doubts the talent. The question is how much of it got scattered across other people's films. Fitzgerald and Faulkner came to Hollywood for the money too, and neither looked back on those years fondly.

Turkish cinema has its own version of this. Some of Yeşilçam's screenwriters wrote hundreds of scripts. That speed built real craft, but it also set a formula trap. Today Turkish television runs the same machine at a different scale, with a new episode every week and each one close to two and a half hours long. A writer who has spent a season inside that machine has no strength left to open the drawer. Nobody writes that into the contract, but everybody knows it.

The commission won't kill you. What kills you is the day its rhythm becomes the rhythm of your own stories.

FourHow the drawer survives

Paul Schrader wrote Taxi Driver with nobody asking for it. He poured it out in a few weeks, out of loneliness, during a dark stretch of his life. It gets told as the purest drawer story there is. But there's another half to it: the script reached the right hands through people Schrader already knew in the business. Even a drawer project has to land on a desk eventually, in front of a producer, in a negotiation.

William Goldman's first original screenplay, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, came out of his own head, and it hit big. In 1967 it sold for one of the highest prices a script had fetched up to then. After that, the same Goldman spent years on commissions and script doctoring. His most famous line about the business, “Nobody knows anything,” holds for both files. There's no guarantee for the commission, and none for your own story either.

So here's the lesson. Your own story stands on the relationships, the reputation and the craft that commissioned work gives you. Do commissions well, and someone will be there to listen when you open the drawer. Do them badly, and that door quietly closes.

FiveRules from the desk

This isn't a list of tips. It's a handful of rules tested at the desk, and you won't like some of them.

  1. Rule

    Don't write it off as “just a paycheck.”

    A commissioned script travels with your name on it. The producer reads it and decides whether to give you the next job. Write the rent script well enough to earn its rent.

  2. Rule

    Smuggle a stowaway onto every commission.

    Slip a feeling, a type of character or a line from the story in your drawer into the commission. Think of the idea Nora Ephron got from her mother: everything is copy. Sometimes the stowaway is what saves the commission.

  3. Rule

    Sell the first hour of the day to yourself.

    This rule falls apart in delivery week. Let it. Pick it up again the week after. A rule's value isn't that it never breaks. It's that you keep coming back to it.

  4. Rule

    Give your own story a fake producer.

    Write a brief for the drawer project too, set a deadline, promise it to someone. The discipline of commissioned work is good for your own story as well. If nobody is waiting for it, find someone who will.

  5. Rule

    Don't turn down the subject you hate. Turn down the one you feel nothing about.

    Hate is fuel. It turns into an antagonist, into irony, into anger. Indifference seeps into the page and never comes out. The real danger is the commission that leaves you cold.

  6. Rule

    Write down what the commission taught you.

    Structure, speed, taking notes, rewriting, cutting the scene you love. Those are the muscles your drawer story will need. A writer who never learned to take notes on their own project falls apart at the first serious note.

  7. Rule

    You can't do your best at both at once. Give each its season.

    Some years are rent years. Accepting that isn't defeat. It's a plan. Defeat is not noticing that the rent year has turned into ten.

LastSo can you do both?

You can, but not as a balancing act. It's more like a pendulum. For a while the commission swallows you, and then for a while your own story does. What sets the masters apart isn't a perfect balance between the two. It's that they never let the pendulum stop. They don't lock the drawer. They just leave it closed for a while.

There's a harsher answer, too: most screenwriters can't do both well. Usually one eats the other. Either the commission machine dries up the drawer, or an obsession with keeping the drawer pure leaves the rent unpaid. Knowing that isn't giving in to fate. It's knowing where the danger is.

The phone will ring again. You'll answer it, because you have to. What matters is whether you keep looking at the drawer after you hang up.

FADE OUT.Scriptopus Mag

Share this piece

Pass it to a writer who would like it.

XLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Keep reading

Scriptopus Mag · Published by Scriptopus. Every piece is free to read.How Scriptopus Mag is made · Pictures via Wikimedia Commons, credited under each one · @scriptopusapp